‘The Scrying Game’ (2021) Witching Hour Psychics (#1) by Christine Zane Thomas, narrated by Jania Edwards

The Scrying Game‘ exceeded my expectations. I’d expected a short, light, cozy mystery with a dash of the supernatural that would keep my wife and me entertained during the course of a long drive. I mean, a woman returns to a small town after inheriting a large old house from an aunt she hasn’t spoken to in years and then discovers that it’s inhabited by a talking cat – we all know how those stories go. If they’re well done, they’re as comforting and as unsurprising as watching an episode of ‘Murder She Wrote‘.

Well, ‘The Scrying Game’ was a comfort read, fitting neatly into the Cozy Supernatural Mystery sub-genre, but there was more to it than I expected. 

Firstly, Willow Brown is not the typical Cozy Mystery main character. She’s a cop, and she’s good at her job. She has some psychic abilities, but they’re not only involuntary, they’re unwanted. She sees the visions that she gets as blighting her life. She’s struggling to keep her marriage alive, and the last thing she wants is to return to her hometown.

Secondly, the mystery at the heart of the plot is a good one. I liked that Willow got a long way to solving it without any supernatural aid. Riding out who did what and why kept the book moving forward and held my attention.

Thirdly, the supernatural elements work. There’s no infordumping and no lazy reliance on tropes. The supernatural elements are presented through Willow’s perception of what’s happening to her, and she brings all her cop scepticism to evaluating that experience. This made it easier to accept the supernatural parts as real and as integral to the action. This was good because some of the action of the plot relies heavily on Willow’s abilities.

This was a satisfying read. I look forward to reading the next book in the series as soon as it becomes available as an audiobook.

I recommend the audiobook. Janina Edwards did a good job in bringing all those Floridian voices to life. Click on the YouTube link below to hear a sample.


Leave a comment