‘A Schooling In Murder’ (2025) by Andrew Taylor, narrated by Nathalie Buscombe – set aside at 26%

IN A NUTSHELL
The premise for this book hooked my imagination. The novel itself sent my imagination to sleep.

A novel offering me a ghost story wrapped around a murder mystery with Dark Academia undertones in a 1940s England historical setting, how could I not enjoy that?


The answer turned out to be: when the pace is so slow and the tension so absent that you lose interest. 


I set this aside at 26% even though the writing and the narration were both good, because the story wasn’t working for me.

The main character was hard to like and was, by necessity, passive (being dead will do that to you). There was no tension and not much by way of pathos or passion. There was a strong sense of how dreary, grubby, small-minded and soul-destroying the school was, but that wasn’t enough to keep me engaged. In the absence of other things, it just made the reading experience depressing. 


I think the main problem was that the pacing of the story didn’t work. It was slow and meandering, with nothing urging me to read the next page. I was a quarter of the way through a murder mystery, and I didn’t care who the murderer was. So, I set the book aside. Life’s too short to snooze through a novel.

Leave a comment