‘Murder By Memory’ (2025) – Dorothy Gentleman #1 by Olivia Waite, narrated by Blair Baker

IN A NUTSHELL
Murder By Memory ‘ was a clever, entertaining, well-written novella that created a whole new world aboard the Fairweather, an interstellar generation ship and solved a crime unique to that environment while introducing a ship’s detective I hope to see more of soon.

‘Murder By Memory‘ is only 100 pages long, but Olivia Waite packed a lot into it and never made me feel I was having data thrust upon me. She opened with the ship’s detective, Dorothy Gentleman, waking in a stalled lift during a magnetic storm, in a body that is not her own. After that, things get stranger and more complicated.

I liked the calm way that Dorothy assessed her situation and eventually discovered and solved the crime that created it. I was comfortable inside her head. As I’d expect from a ship’s detective, she was observant, suspicious, and relentless in her desire to know what really happened and who was responsible. She was also as kind as her role allowed. She showed empathy for others and was haunted by a recent loss of her own. I liked that she was as curious about people as she is about solving puzzles.

The worldbuilding was deftly done. I quickly got a feel for the setup of this generation ship on which people will live for a millennium, using a succession of bodies updated from a single ‘book’ that stores their memories and personalities. The characters were exotic but engaging. Fairweather is full of all kinds of interesting people, although CIS white males seem to be very much a minority. The crime was ingenious. I even liked the AI running the ship, especially as the magnetic storm had made it cheerfully tipsy when we first met.

Both Dorothy Gentlemen and the Fairweather offer a wealth of opportunities for future stories. I’m looking forward to reading them.


Olivia Waite writes queer historical romance, fantasy, science fiction, and essays.

She has ten novels in print in addtion to Murder By Memory.

She is the romance fiction columnist for the New York Times Book Review.

Leave a comment